Monday, June 04, 2012

The Caustic Elf on "Bounded Accuracy"

I just read the latest scroll from Seabattle titled Bounded Accuracy and for all the wisdom granted to me at birth by the tree gods I can't make sense out of what they're saying.  It seems to be a collage of the undecipherable and the obvious.  I'll try to interpret it again after casting read bullshit on it as a 12th level magic user.


Let us start with this: "Conventional D&D wisdom tells us that the maxim "the numbers go up" is an inherent part of the class and level progression in D&D. While that might be true, in the next iteration of the game we're experimenting with something we call the bounded accuracy system." Let me try casting that read bullshit again.  Something must have gone wrong with the spell because I can't make shit of what they're saying.  Are they implying that progression now means numbers going down?  I can come up with a few cases in which numbers going down is a mark of progression: credit card payments, weight loss and unemployment rates.  None of which seems to apply to D&D.  So what the fuck are they coming up with?  Another number to hide a value that's already hiding another value?  Mhhh, I'm confused.  Did someone cast a baffle spell on me?  I don't recall rolling the saving throw.


Next.


"The basic premise behind the bounded accuracy system is simple: we make no assumptions on the DM's side of the game that the player's attack and spell accuracy, or their defenses, increase as a result of gaining levels.", but the numbers increase do wether you make the assumption or not. " Instead, we represent the difference in characters of various levels primarily through their hit points, the amount of damage they deal, and the various new abilities they have gained. ", vs prior editions which represented it how? Did you notice how it's all about damage and health and being strong to survive damage.  Where the fuck has role play gone?  Oh yea, probably scattered among those "new abilities".  "Characters can fight tougher monsters not because they can finally hit them, but because their damage is sufficient to take a significant chunk out of the monster's hit points; likewise, the character can now stand up to a few hits from that monster without being killed easily, thanks to the character's increased hit points."  This is wrong on so many levels its fucking infuriating.  We start out reading about the "bounded system", but they they forget about the 'no assumptions' on player's attack accuracy and defenses half way through the fucking paragraph.  How do they come about to deliver more damage?  Better hit bonuses, that's how.  How are the more resistant?  More hit points.  All those are increased numerical values that increase with level.  It's not due to a skill gained called "open your eyes" or "grip a sword tightly".  It's pure numeric advantage so I don't see the point in this 'Bounded accuracy' labeling they've got.  " Furthermore, gaining levels grants the characters new capabilities, which go much farther toward making your character feel different than simple numerical increases."  Wrong again. Two characters can have the same numerical values and still be two different characters altogether.  That's what role play is about.  Look it up for fuck's sake.  You're overstepping by trying to make the rules and mechanics fill in for role play.  It's not, get over it.


Next.


"Now, note that I said that we make no assumptions on the DM's side of the game about increased accuracy and defenses. This does not mean that the players do not gain bonuses to accuracy and defenses.", what?  I think these smart fellas mean to say that the DM should make no assumption as to 'the value' increase as clearly there is an increase.  It's the assumption on the rate or value that's in question.  So is this turd thought called Bounded Accuracy about increase or rate of increase.  It seems bounded accuracy is about bounded increases per level as we'll see next. " It does mean, however, that we do not need to make sure that characters advance on a set schedule, and we can let each class advance at its own appropriate pace. ", holy shit!!!  I sure hope they didn't do some uber long quest to an oracle to figure that one out.  Isn't that the point of class differences?  If classes didn't advance at their own appropriate pace, but rather at some other pace they'd be another class.  A class which advances at said other rate.  For example :" Thus, wizards don't have to gain a +10 bonus to weapon attack rolls just for reaching a higher level in order to keep participating; if wizards never gain an accuracy bonus, they can still contribute just fine to the ongoing play experience.", no fucking shit Sherlock.  A wizard doesn't have to gain a +10 bonus to weapon attack in order to keep participating.  If it did have to it wouldn't be a wizard class it would be a fucking fighter class!!!!  Holy shit this read bullshit spell is really kicking in.


Next.


"This extends beyond simple attacks and damage. We also make the same assumptions about character ability modifiers and skill bonuses.", you mean "not make the same assumptions", right?  Your editor should cast the read bullshit spell before editing this because it seems he's getting tangled in it.  You start off by making no assumptions about increased accuracy and defenses, but now you are making assumptions?  Which way is it? " Thus, our expected DCs do not scale automatically with level, and instead a DC is left to represent the fixed value of the difficulty of some task, not the difficulty of the task relative to level.", holy crap isn't this obvious?  I mean since when did DC checks increase with character level.  Isn't this stating the obvious?  You're making this whole article because your players increase DC values for the same exact physical lock as characters raise in level?  Fix that then.  


The article then goes on for quite some length touching other topics.  I'll go over them briefly as there is no fucking way this read bullshit spell lasts long enough to cover it all thoroughly.


Benefits of the Bounded Accuracy:


Getting better at something means actually getting better at something


Holy shit they figured that one out on their own?  Shit I could read that one out without the read bullshit spell.  Must be the one logical thing in the whole article.


Nonspecialized characters can more easily participate in many scenes

You can do that with a little thing called "role play".  Not everything needs to be about attack or defense.  In a role play game it is actually a good thing to once in a while get some role play done.  Secondly the issue with low level characters failing skill tests is due to the poorly done linear probability distribution mechanism.  Not the "bounded accuracy".

The DM's monster roster expands, never contracts

This one is always a kicker for me.  I remember back in the day I always asked were the fuck those goblins hid away.  When I was first level I'd go out of the city walls and encounter a couple of goblins that afternoon.  A year later I'm 6th level, I step outside the bastion towers and holy shit 25 goblins meet me.  Where the fuck where they?  What did they eat?  It's this lack of world economics that lets DMs do this and the truth is it gets boring after time.  It's a flaw in the system.  The increase in hit points to represent better fighting skills leads to monster inflation.  Fix hit points and you fix a lot of issues.

Bounded accuracy makes it easier to DM and easier to adjudicate improvised scenes

Crap.  I couldn't understand that even with the read bullshit spell.  

It opens up new possibilities of encounter and adventure design

Shit, have I been dungeon crawling so long?  Back in the day it was called henchmen.  What happened to those?  It was usually a good idea to engage a superior enemy with large numbers of sellswords.  Heck I even lead armies to battle.  As in real army combat system rules.  Is that gone now?  Shit.

It is easier for players and DMs to understand the relative strength and difficulty of things

This is sad.  Not only has mass combat systems been discontinued.  Simple math is a goner too?!?!!?  It's fucking easy to understand relative strength.  One creature has 1d8 damage and one attack another has 1d10 damage and 2 attacks.  That's 2.5 times more max damage 8 vs 20.  

It's good for verisimilitude

I love this part.  Even with the read bullshit spell at full blast I had trouble getting this.  It seems we need the "bounded accuracy" so easy things stay easy and hard things stay hard. So I enter a dungeon at first level and the chest is easy to open.  Then I go back five levels later and the same exact chest is now hard to open.  What the fuck happened there?  Are we adding a "bounded accuracy" system because some stupid player forgot the "common sense" system during playtest?  


I'll give you my version of the "bounded accuracy".  Play, plan and use common sense.  If you can't figure that one out no amount of added rules will fix it for you.



Sunday, June 03, 2012

Really playing Era for the first time

Well last night on the bus from Guadalajara back to Mexico City a quick game started on Facebook.  Yea Facebook.  A small thread started in the local role play group inquiring about what RPGs are transformed into a game when asked "so what else do we need to start playing", I said "well you're role playing now as we speak".  No dice had been rolled, no characters created, just ideas of what the player wanted to be.  Two more players quickly joined the thread which became a chat and then another one joined the group and the chat.

Half an hour later one player was a monk traveling north and finding himself stranded in a walled city after the caravan he was traveling with  turned west and up river.  Needing to find a new party he became acquainted with someone who recommended a local guide (the second player).  Who is a rogue like character with "special" skills.  While waiting for the guide to arrive the monk meets the third player a gypsy bard who sings some tunes to his name.  A small brawl between the "guide" and the gypsy over the gypsy being a treacherous one.  Strangely a stampeding city guard forces the gypsy to decide between getting the coins hes earned singing or jumping to save these folks he just met.  He saves them and loses his gold.  At that point we stopped.  The last character a female elven ranger druid will have to join the group a while later.

I'm really interested in this game as it's the first time I use the rules with an inexperienced group of players.  The possibilities seem endless and they're not skewed by preconceptions of what RPG, of what can and can't be allowed by the rules.  I looking forward to keeping it like that.  The characters make the rules around simple mechanics.  The monk is a brewer who borders on alchemist as he's so good.  Some secret power will come from that.  Maybe beer potion making?  The gypsy bard sounds like a very interesting character.  Music and rogue put together.  A musical street wise character?  The rogue is the least polished one as the player joined in late.  Finally the elf will be the last to join the group.  We'll see how she turns out.

So far I'm thrilled at been saying "yes", "yes" and "yes" to things.  Nothing seems to prone to breaking the rules.  We are building characters based on pseudoclasses called templates and fine tuning them not based on skills, but rather roles.  Actually they don't know this, it's all going on in my head.  But the game's roles packed in collegia can then be built into game settings.  As a game master I'll later flesh out the gypsy collegia based on player interestes and my own ideas.  Which is what I'm looking for.  Going from player ideas/interests to roles to character creation.  Instead of proposing a character class to which the player must mold himself to.

The magic system seem to be able to supply all that is coming, alchemy? sure, druid spells ? yes.  Ranger and druid multiclassing, sure thing.   Just put the two collegia into the character and let her play it out.  She and the monk will be superbly strong characters.  Yet I'm not worried as the XP tax system will benefit the others.  The monk and the druid will rise slower now.  Letting the others level out.  Added to that the characters are playing what they want.   I think this is key in preventing max-min issues as they'll maximise their character no the character stats.  That means fleshing out to maximize character feel rather than character combat capacity.  I mean what better than being an alchemist-brewer.  That idea has me enthralled in the options for great role play.  Good starting point for so many things and quite a strong power if used wisely.

Well enough for now.  I'm just getting home.  Off to a shower and some rest.

Friday, June 01, 2012

Thoughts on D&D and Magic The Gathering

Well last Wednesday I had the opportunity to get back to playing Magic The Gathering which I haven't played for about two years.  It was with a group of players I just met, some of whom also role play.  The whole event gave me a lot to think about D&D.  The monsters were some kick ass things way stronger than I had played a few years back yet the rules where pretty much the same as when I started playing in the late 90's.  On top of that some of the players, who didn't role play, didn't do so because they though it was too hard.  To many die rolls and rules.  I was like are you kidding me?  Read these cards you have fifty something cards on your deck, complicated powers and compound powers, and spells, and enchantments, and what not.  A deck provides a huge combination, and that is only a subset of the combinations provided by Magic as a whole.

These players have hand picked those cards from a huge set of options.  Made a very strong setup of cards for play and yet they may win or they may lose.  It got me thinking why can't WotC owners of Magic also do the same thing for D&D.  No, I don't mean make D&D into a card game I mean:

  • Make D&D a game with long lasting rules.
  • Make D&D a game with simple rules.  The complexity in Magic appears in the cards not the rules.
  • Make D&D a balanced game no matter how strong the powers are.  Magic has standard cards and the special ones.  You can't play tournaments with the special decks, but you can have fun at home.  Yet even with the special decks it's hard to ensure a certain win.  There is still balance.
  • Make D&D a profitable game.
When I read the stuff coming out of D&D I see the opposite of Magic.  Very simple character classes (cards) and a very complex set of rules.  I wonder, shouldn't it be the other way around?  Shouldn't Mike Mearls and crew cross the isle and see what Magic is doing and get some tips?  For example:
  • Reduce D&D to no more than 10 rules or so.  Make it fit into 20 to 30 pages.  Like the basic edition.
  • Open up a zillion classes and powers.  Magic has the white cards, and the black ones, and the green ones, and the blue ones, and red ones, and probably more I don't know or recall.  It has creatures, and spells, and artifacts, and also more I don't know or recall.  Can't D&D do some equivalent to character class, skills, power, spells, etc.  with that?
  • Place the "modular" part on the "cards" (read: classes, spells, skills, powers) not on the rules.  Sell "modules" with ideas, thoughts, inspiration and all that which gets the campaign going.  Do what Magic does and "sell cards" or the equivalent you come up with for D&D.
Mike, based on your D&D Next if you were selling us Magic The Gathering "Next"  we'd get the following:
  • Forty cards.  That includes character classes, spells and some extra thing.  It would also be all the cards to ever exist in the Magic The Gathering "Next" universe.  Contrary to the thousands it actually has.
  • Three books (aprox 600 pages) on how to play Magic The Gathering "Next".  Contrary to the short booklet you get with the starter set.
Do you see the difference Mike?  Do you see how you're failing to fill us with inspiration, awe and desire to role play?  Your game is too freaking complex and has little substance.  Turn it around!!!  Give us a booklet of rules and a basic set of "sixty cards".  Then engage us with more and more "cards", not "rules".

Thursday, May 31, 2012

The Caustic Elf on D&D Next's modular magic

Reading the latest Mage Mearls scroll from Seabattle made kissing a burnt troll feel like a damned wet dream.  The raven brought this scroll today and I'll address the first question and its answer.


Question : "What about worlds where magic is more abundant or powerful, or worlds with even less magic? Do you think there will be modular rules for making magic more or less powerful for different games in D&D Next?"


Me! Me! I can answer that one.  Fuck I mean a 5 year old could answer it for Mage Mearls.  The answer is.... (drums).... the Dungeon Master handles that when he builds his world.   But let's give Mage Mearls a break and look at his response.



"Absolutely, and I think magic is one of the places where we will spend plenty of time on optional rules. First, we're already taking a step to make sure that magic items don't figure deeply into the core math of the game, making it easier to run a Dark Sun-esque game where finding magic loot is more rare. "  Wo ho ho there editor hold the press.  What the fuck is he saying?  Last time I played a Dark Sun "esque" whateverish game it was damn fucking easy to do.  You went out and bought Dark Sun, tore open the wrapping and started playing.  Really, honest to the tree gods.  It was that simple.  You didn't need to write core game math.  Fuck I doubt they even have a game math.   By the recent crap coming out of Wish-a-ton kingdom it seems game and math on the same sentence are an oxymoron.  But I digress, sorry.  Back on track.  Having more or less magic in a setting was done the following way a) the DM allows it or b) the DM doesn't allow it.  That's it.  No quantum mechanics or string theory.  But let's keep listening to the Mage's wise words again.


"Beyond that, we want to provide ways to turn the "quantity of magic" dial (as well as the "quality of magic dial," but that might be a whole different discussion) up or down as you please. "   Wo ho ho hold it again.  Dial?  Who is "you" in the "as you please".  Is he addressing the Dungeon Master?  If so why the fuck would he want a dial.  He's the bloody fucking Dungeon Master.  Has Mage Mearls forgotten what that fucking means.  He's the god's god.  He's the world.  He's everything.  He's the Dungeon Master.  He doesn't need no fucking dial he IS the dial.  Now on the other hand Mage Mearls might be addressing the players.  In which case I'm obliged to raise the question.  What exactly does he mean by a dial?  A set of rules so the players can grab the Dungeon Master by the balls and use them as the dial to raise or lower the magic setting as they will?  I mean as a character I've had moments in which I wished the Dungeon Master wasn't such a pig.  But he's the Dungeon Master, if you take that away from him what's the fate of the game?  Over specialization.  Imbalance.  All that which we dislike in D&D.  But of course that gives room for Mage Mearls to crank out more scrolls (at a cost for us) to regulate the problems created by his regulation of needs that were solved by fucking common sense when I was adventuring.

Anyway let's finish reading the answer. 

"Want to run a low-magic game? We can make the rules for turning at-will magic into 1st-level spells, criteria for ability score requirements for spellcasters, and guidelines for using only ritual magic and not normal spellcasting. Want to run a high-magic game? Give everybody two at-will spells, and here are three special themes designed specifically for a high-magic campaign. ".  Holy fucking crap.  Can't seem to get past two sentences without getting ogre blisters on my balls.  What the fuck is this?  Rules to regulate the obvious.  If you want a high-magic campaign you need to have more magic in it.  Give more things to players.  I mean isn't that the definition of high-magic?  What next?  Rules to make a hard dungeon.  What's the Mage going to write?  I can hear him already.  "We can create rules for harder dungeons that add more monsters and traps".  Holy shit Mage I think our devote readers can figure that one out on their own.

Lets keep reading.  

"When it comes to creating campaign themes (and I consider "low magic" and "high magic" to be campaign themes, though they may not be the only ones used in a given campaign), the process isn't always going to be as simple as just providing a single optional rule; sometimes, it is going to involve a few variant rules, an optional rule or two, and maybe some player-centric elements (themes, backgrounds, spells, etc.) that are only available in that thematic campaign."

That's why you don't make rules for this Mage!!  You make settings.  That should be the answer to the question.  No rules for high magic or low magic settings.  There is more or less magic, but the rules, the way magic works is the same.

The Caustic Elf's First Round Overview of D&D Next's Playtest First Round Overview

It seems all these long forgotten adventurers are coming out of the dungeons where they were left behind by the most recent D&D versions.  And they seem to be coming out bitching about everything.  It seems the dungeon they've been exploring or should I say the rules aren't quite what they used to be a decade or more ago.  Dwarves, halflings and now elves are pouring out complaining about the hell they've been in during D&D 3 and 4 and screaming at what 5 seems to be turning into.


The Caustic Elf just read a scroll delivered by a raven from the mighty city state of Seabattle in the kingdom of Wish-a-ton.  His skin almost drowed itself pitch black from what he read.  I leave you now with the Caustic Elf in person.


Thank you thank you o great lord Saurondor master of the most pissed barren lands a dungeon master has ever gamed in.  I appreciate this opportunity to rant, ejem, I mean pour my opinion on the news from Seabattle.  It seems my long years adventuring have not been paying off too much.  The most recent news I have received come in this scroll.  I have to say I'm appalled with what I read.  It's not enough to have been rolling all those d20s missing my skill check for no apparent reason.  Now I have to read this:


" Advantage and disadvantage used to be a –2 penalty. By rolling two dice and taking the higher or lower result, we hope to make it easier to resolve situations that call for these rolls."


What the fuck?  Adding a number is harder than rolling two dice and comparing.  What about the change in probabilities.  Why doesn't Mage Mearls talk about that.  No oh no.  He goes on and explains that a good reason for this is : 

"it's much more forgiving if you forget to apply it, but have already picked up your d20 (and can't remember what the result of the die roll was). "


And can't remember what the die roll was?  And you forgot to apply your bonus?  Is he fucking nuts?  You're making a rule and endorsing it because some dim wit can't remember to add a bonus?  I know people want to forget bad news and forgetting a bad die roll is understandable, a fucking week later, but you just rolled the die!  Shit, I mean what next?  The DM says you suffer 12 hit points of damage and you forget that by the time you pick up your pencil to write it down on the character sheet.  "Excuse me DM, how many hit points?"  What happens if the DM forgets too!?!?!?  Oh and it gets better.  Get a load of this:


"The same applies to disadvantage. If you hit and picked up the die, you can just roll again. If the second roll misses, you missed."

Oh so fucking great.  If I forget to add a disadvantage but I hit like hell am I going to remind the DM, gosh you know what I forgot.  So I get a second chance to fail.  Did you also notice how it's like five lines touching the "I forget" topic and one covering the "it's easier to add".


Well there's lots of ground to cover, next. "For instance, you can't pick a lock without thieves' tools." 


Holy shit! A whole new set of rules to say the obvious.  I don't recall a version that allowed to pick locks without tools.  But then again I've been in the dungeon so long I might have missed it.  Nonetheless it seems quite obvious.  Maybe Mage Mearl's age is showing and his memory failing, but for me this is quite clear.


I'm going to add this one " We assume that swimming, climbing, and jumping don't require any special checks." to the same rant.  I mean hasn't it always been like that?  I walk into a calm pond and drown?  I don't know how Mage Mearls has been playing the game the last few years.  Maybe he's used to a skill check for walking and talking too.  Doesn't it seem like Mage Mearls is making rules to regulate the rules that shouldn't be there in the first place?  Maybe he's been failing his "write game rules" skill check as of lately (last 6 months).

Onto stealth now.  The Mage says "To design stealth, we first decided that we wanted rogues to be able to hide in situations where other characters cannot."  Oh boy did that bring images of the Pink Panther to my head and the inspector walking right in front oblivious to the Panther's presence.


"Anyone can try to hide in darkness or if they are fully obscured from view."


Holy  crap Mage Mearls you just defined hiding.  If you're fully obscured from view you're hidden.  Your statement can be rewritten "Anyone can try to hide in darkness or if they are hidden".  But it doesn't end there. "If a rogue hides and no one is around to see him, don't bother with rolling the dice unless".  Like no shit Sherlock!  When did common sense leave the game?  Have past editions been such a hand holding experience that game masters are treated like small children.  I mean really small children like 2 years old.


Last but not least Spells : " The spell rules should look familiar to 3E fans. The big change here is in the spell description. We wanted something that was fun to read, so we decided to fall back on plain language rather than a formal stat block."


Arrrgghhhhhh holy shit crap fuck.  What is this??  All these months and all they can come up with is a nicer description for spells!  Something nicer to read.  Isn't that the dungeon master's job to describe.  Maybe in the new drone mechanics focused on combat things like "narrative" have become ancient customs.  But there was a time when a short description was enough to get the game masters and players inspired.  Is this the illness of D&D in this day and age?  Over detailed rules that actually play out the adventure rather than set the guidelines for a great adventure.  Trying and failing to lay down in text the most important rule in RPGs: "common sense".


Well that's enough for today.  There's more in the scroll, but it blisters my skin just to read it again.  I'll enjoy a tea now and wait for the next raven to arrive.


Your's trully,
Caustic Elf


Well thank you Caustic Elf for your comments it's put some points into perspective.  Folks don't miss his post on magic here.  Being an elven fighter-magic user Caustic has been quite strongly opinionated on this matter.

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Using 2d20 for hit roll (as in 1d20 + 1d20, not the weird other stuff)

Well I've been exploring new combat mechanisms these last few months and although I have the combat mechanics well set I'm still fiddling with the hit roll.  I'm looking into non linear probability distributions as a way to determine a hit or a miss.

Why this?  Excitement.  If the probability of certain numbers is greater the action will concentrate on those values rather than spread all over the place.  I started out with 2d10 that has a mode of 11.  Rolls will tend to fall around 11 unlike 1d20 which can fall anywhere.  A one can happen as frequently as a 10, or a 14.

My combat rules say anything above a 10 is a hit.  So there are high odds of hitting your target.  Although to be honest there is about the same chance of hitting as if you just rolled 1d20.  Let us take a look at the curve on the graph below.  The black line is the 1d20 and the blue line is 2d10.  As you can see the cross just about the middle.  Around 10 or 11.  So what's the difference.  Well the slope.  Notice how the blue line becomes steeper as it approaches 9 and begins to level of at 14.  Six numbers 9, 10, 11, 12, 13 and 14 tend to occur 50% of the time.  Almost as often as the remaining 14.  It's quite probable to get a value near 10 of above it.  What does this do for the game?

This creates excitement in the battle as there is hit after hit.  Now that doesn't mean damage.  Under my rules the opposing party can parry or dodge and does so with 2d10 too.  That means the defenders roll is prone to land near the attackers roll.  Which is what I look for in using 2d10.   Not an 18 by the attacker and a 2 by the defender.  I mean what the heck happened there?  Defenders's cell phone rang?  Not likely.  So those cases when it seems the defender was not paying any attention to this life threatening fight are gone.  Surely a low roll will happen.  People mess up, slip or whatever.  But not usually, rarely.

Using 2d10 gives value to experience and training.  It's less probable to get low values below 7.  A +3 bonus takes you to 10 and you score a hit.  Just barely maybe and the defender can still parry and succeed in preventing damage.  But this is more akin to real life.  A well trained fighter gives an unskilled one his run for the money.  The unskilled fighter has to try its best while a trained one hits with a somewhat poor hit roll of 7.  The curve also makes becoming uber good very hard.  Toward the edges the curves slopes decrease and that means that every plus to hit means less.  If our fighter rolls a 3 on the 1d20 he gets an effective 6 after his +3.  The graph shows us that 75% of the rolls are above 6 for a 1d20, but 85% of the rolls on a 2d10 are above 6.  So parrying is easier for the defender when the attacker fumbles bad.  So training won't save the attacker so easily from a big mistake. The mistakes are rarer, but when they happen they are hard to hand wave away.

So if 2d10 is so nice, why 2d20.  Well let's change the rules a bit so the hit roll is 2d20 (added for a 2 to 40 range).  Any value rolled equal or greater to 20 represents a hit.  On the graph below the 2d20 curve is shown in orange.  Notice how the 2d10 (blue) curve is way steeper than the 2d20.  Every plus on the to hit roll is too much of an advantage if you want to allow a lot of training skills and magic.  The 2d20 roll provides a more gradual slope that is similar to the 1d20 in the 25 to 75 percentile range.  But also has longer tails to each side.  A +3 gives you a 75% probability of hitting your target on the 2d20 while being 80 to 85% certain on the 2d10.  If you get a lucky shot of 35 it will be hard for a +3 fighter to reach you as he'll more often than not land between 16 and 27.

This makes overspecialization very hard and expensive to the point of being unviable.  For a fighter to stop even the most luckiest of shots would mean getting a +10 or +15.  How much would that cost him in experience and training.  If you add the suggested rules for a self regulating game the player would soon realize that the points spent in reaching these extreme benefits would be best invested in other fields which create a lesser XP burden on the character's progression.

So 2d20 rolls gives a good distribution with a nice set of common values.  The slope is lower than for the 2d10, so each extra plus gives less benefit to the character.  So it allows the game to have more bonus levels, magic, spells and items that grant pluses to hit while not allowing the creation of super characters.  The tails at both ends make it harder to secure a hit or parry in the game with a 100% certainty.  A character with a +8 (not very hard to get) can guarantee a hit on a 1d20 and 2d10 system.  But hes a long shot from perfect on the 2d20.  He's damn good, but not flawless.

Thoughts?



Monday, May 21, 2012

Era - página de descarga

Aquí encontrarás los links para descargar la más reciente versión del rpg Era






Hit Points, our eternal nemesis

Mike Mearls just published article regarding hit points in D&D Next (or as some would call it D&D Collage). In it he covers the explanation of what hit points mean in the D&D system. You can read the article here.

In the article Mearls say "In D&D Next, hit points and Hit Dice are an abstraction that we use to model more than just a character's physical durability. In fact, we have three elements that tie into a character's hit points and Hit Dice." He then lists three points which I'll briefly reproduce here for clarity.
  • Physical capacity for punishment, which is measured through a combination of size, bulk, and durability. [...] 
  • Energy and experience, which is measured by a creature's ability to turn a direct hit into a glancing blow and ignore minor aches and pains. [...] 
  • Luck and cosmic significance, which is the simple truth that in a world of high magic, gods, and planar powers, some creatures are consigned by fate to take on a great task. [...]


I'm totally turned down by their incapacity to think outside the box. When I hear the name "D&D Next" I imagine the next best thing. Not a remake of the old rules which also happen to bring forth one of the greatest problems with D&D: "excessive hit points". A problem in D&D I call "hit point fuge". Hit point fuge is the problem presented in a campaign when characters reach too many hit points. The adventure requires ever escalating monsters because characters don't suffer any real damage until they're practically down to 0 hit points. On top of this there's the issue with the clerics. It is ironic that Mearls mentions the following in the same article, "We want to make the cleric as optional for a group as a fighter, wizard, or rogue. [...] First, it's worth noting why we want to reduce the party's reliance on healing magic." That seems contradictory to the beginning. More hit points or reliance on hit points to represent all that he mentions makes the cleric NOT optional for a group. When hit point fuge kicks in players hack and slash and then power up on hit points to hack and slash again. The low level risk of dying disappears when the characters hit points way exceed the monsters potential for a kill in one blow.

I would suggest the following addendum to the rules if game masters want to actually do what Mike preaches. That is actually reduce the dependency on cleric and create a really captivating and epic adventure.

  • Don't do away with hit points, just make them fixed for life at a somewhat high value. Say between 15 and 25. The game rules I use set hit points at constitution + 1d10. 
  • Add another value called stamina. Stamina is actually a representation of all that which Mearls attributes to hit points. Damage happens to stamina first then hit points. 
  • Use a value I call Pain Threshold. This is the amount of stamina points above which hit point damage is inflicted. I've set the value at 10% of stamina. 
  • Stamina recovers quite quickly at a rate of 5 per hour + constitution bonuses. 
How does this work? Suppose a character has 20 hit points, 60 stamina

and a pain threshold of 6 (10% of 60). Any damage under 6 HP goes to stamina. So a character can suffer 12 hits doing 5 HP each and suffer no real life threatening damage. But a hit for 10 HP does 6 stamina points of damage an 4 hit points of damage. Stamina acts as a shield, but not an invulnerable one.

This mechanism does provide a solution in which stamina is a representation of a character's endurance and does away for the need to carry a cleric around all the time. First of all players will think their encounters better before they engage. In this example 26 hit points of damage still kill the character (20 HP + 6 pain threshold). When in the classic rules it would take 80 hit points of damage (20 HP + 60 stamina). Thus the cleric might not be helpful in time given the fast pace of combat. Secondly stamina heals quickly. So in combat a character might suffer 5 hit points of damage and 38 stamina points of damage. Those hit points may take days to heal, but the stamina will fully recover on its own in 8 hours or less.

Thoughts?

PS: Mearls might also want to include parry and dodge to the combat phase. The game system these rules belong to contemplate parry and dodge and thus the pain threshold is low. For D&D game master who don't want to rewrite the combat rules might want to experiment with higher stamina and pain threshold values.

Friday, May 18, 2012

New Universal RPG Combat Mechanics

After some time reviewing, rewriting, testing and simulating a bit I have a first revision for the mechanism I proposed back in February.  These rules are meant to be universal in nature.  Setting the groundwork for the steps to resolve combat and to be able to do so in different settings.  From medieval fantasy adventure to futuristic sci-fi.


You can download the document for my rules for the universal combat mechanics here:

Combat Mechanics

Enjoy!

Feedback as always is welcome.  Stay tuned I'm working on some futuristic weapons and armors for this system.

Wednesday, May 16, 2012

Principle for a self balancing game

Well I've given it some thought on the matter of balancing classes and gameplay in general.  There has been a great deal of conversation on this issue given Wizard's work on the D&D next.  Even Monte Cook recently asked the question, "It is difficult (not impossible) to create a character creation system for an rpg that allows for customization of capabilities that doesn't greatly encourage optimization." By optimization we mean min-max issues that lead to over specialized characters that unbalance the game or take too much "action" from the others.  


This begs me to ask the question:  If you could would you be able to prove it?


Ok, so what if I can come up with a character creation system that allows for customization without encouraging optimization.  How do I know it discourages optimization given all the possible combinations a character may take?  Do I play test all possible scenarios?  Well that is truly impossible.  It's like knowing all the RPG adventures that will ever happen before the rules go to print.  Or limit adventure/character options to such a limited set the game becomes boring.  Which is against the ideals of RPG in the first place.


So this got me thinking about the whole objective of building a character generation system and its relevance in game balance.  I arrived at the conclusion that it is totally irrelevant to game balance.  It might appear so, but in truth it isn't.  It's like shooting and unguided rocket to the Moon and hoping it lands safely there or at least enters Moon orbit.  It won't.  It will fly towards it.  It will seem to get close, but it will miss by a long shot.  No matter how good you do the initial trajectory calculations without onboard flight control you will miss the Moon.


The secret I believe is to create "onboard flight control" for the RPG.  That means less concentration on the character generation and more concentration on the gaming side.  Define "balance" in the game and give it some numeric value.  Then rank characters against it and keep tabs on things as they evolve.  This requires a different character sheet system (or recording system if you will).  One that keeps tabs on how strong the character is.  Numerically!


So far I've seen no system that does this.  Point buy systems provide XP or means to adquire more skills, but there is no clear "feedback" link between the amount of skill points given and the way XP is supplied.  Class based systems rely on levels to "supply" skills which are acquired at each level and the level-class combo is presumed to be balanced at design time when in truth it isn't so.  Because skills can cause unwanted synergies and not all skills are the same even if they can be acquired at the same level.  There is no "skill weight" if you will allow me the expression.  With such a value you could rank the character, but D&D lacks it.


So I propose the following.  Quit trying to balance the game from the character generation point of view and look to balance it during game play.  One way I see of doing this is to create and index or value that shows how strong the character is.


To implement this index I coined a term called XP Tax.  Once a skill is added to the character the character's XP tax is increased.  The XP tax is in turn a % of the XP gained in every adventure that is "lost" to upkeep of current skills.  The greater the skill count the greater the tax and the slower the progression is.  It is also a good index to measure characters with.  If you have a party with members having 18%, 22% and 47% XP tax you have a balance issue.  This XP tax mechanism provides what is known as "negative feedback" on the character progression mechanism.  It is negative because the stronger the character the more negative the feedback value (increased XP).  In spite of the term "negative", negative feedback is a good thing.  Like the rocket shooting to the Moon.  The negative feed back in the guidance system works to reduce the error between the rocket's path and the Moon's position.  In a similar way this feedback keeps the character at check.


So now instead of best guessing the character class progression during class design time you have a mechanism that allows you to measure the class as it advances.  More so it "decouples" skills and skill design from character class design.  If at some point you find out that some skill or power is actually too strong you just need to increase its XP tax to account for its bigger impact on the character class.  So you can fine tune the system during playttest without having to go back to the character class drawing board, and you don't have to redesign the whole class to fix an issue.  This is what "decoupling" means.  Things are no longer tightly bound together and small changes to the parts don't affect the whole as much.


With this it is an easy matter to create an exponential XP tax progression for some skills.  For example basic proficiency in a weapon might cost you 1 XP tax point, expert 2,  master 4.  Two weapon fighting might double your XP cost for the used weapons.  So if you have 8 XP tax for long sword and 4 for dagger thats 12 XP tax points base.  Add two weapon and that becomes 24 XP tax points.  That's a lot of XP lost every adventure to have such a skill.  It's a great skill to have, but it has got to be worth it for the player.  Maybe those 12 points would be better used somewhere else?


The graph below shows the impact of XP tax on various XP incomes and the possibility of purchasing skills.  This measures the skill purchasing power and it is plotted on a logarithmic scale.  It goes from 2 on the outer rim to -2 on the center.  The inner circle represents 0 or "unity gain" (one hundred times less progression speed than the outer rim).  Each color represents an average XP income per adventure.  Starting characters would average 1000 XP points and as they progress they will be able to tackle harder adventures that bring in more XP (2000, 4000,... etc).  The percentage values represent the XP tax.  The graph starts with 5% a very low tax value representing starting characters.  As characters increase in skills their XP tax increases as well going counter clockwise on the graph.


If a starter character with 5% XP tax could bring in 32000 XP points per adventure it's progression would be monstrous as you can see the light blue triangle is nearly on the 2 (100 times faster than the inner circle of 0).  But lets be realistic.  How can such a weak character gain so much XP in a single adventure?  Not going to happen.  So we take the more realistic value of 1000 XP points which is closer to the inner circle of unity progression, but slightly above it.


As it gains experience the character then increases its skills and goes up to 10%, then 15% and then 20%.  At that point the blue square has fallen nearly to the inner circle and the orange diamond is now where the blue square used to be.  XP tax is such that progression at a rate of 2000 to 4000 XP per adventure is now equivalent to the early 1000 XP tax.  This coupled with ever more expensive skills keeps the system under control.  If players spend too much on certain skills their XP tax can skyrocket too early in their game and they find themselves doing an uphill climb from there on.  If the points cross the inner circle to negative values the progression is practically impossible.  So it is good to keep the number between the inner circle and halfway to the outer circle.


Thoughts?



Saturday, May 12, 2012

Balancing skills and synergy

A recent conversation regarding customization and rules abuse to obtain certain optimization benefits got me thinking in the need to balance skill point assignment.  Optimization occurs when a player customizes a character in an extreme way that leads to game balance issues.  In the particular case of D&D I believe this is due to the linear nature of skill rank and point assignment.  There is no increased cost for improving a rank as long as you're level is high enough.  So going from 3 to 4 costs the same as going from 8 to 9.  This makes it very easy for a player to optimize certain skills and become ubber good at something.

If costs were cuadratic then it would cost considerably more to go from 8 to 9 than 3 to 4.  Quite prohibitively so.  Players would soon reach a point in which raising the rank of a skill does not provide the benefit enough to justify the cost.  It is much better to improve in other fields that would be cheaper and give a better point to benefit ratio.

As I solution I've been working on an XP tax system that accounts for the character's constant training to keep skills in shape.  The more you're skilled at something the more you'll have to pay to keep up that skill.  So overly skilled characters would pay a heavy XP tax.  This tax is literally deducting from XP assignment.  If you earn 2000 XP in an adventure and your tax is 10% you only get 1800 XP.

This makes players think twice about optimizing a value.  As a high skill doesn't only cost a lot to get it keeps costing on and on and on.  The higher XP tax derived from that skill affects all gameplay.  So a high skill kept to be used in combat for some specific advantage costs the player a lot of XP even if it wasn't used at all during a particular adventure.

Obviously this does not prevent optimization, but is sure promotes its disuse.  Players that are willing to pay the high price for an overly optimized character are free to optimize, but their advancement will be hindered in comparison to others.

¿Thoughts?

Wednesday, May 09, 2012

It pays to play with class

I guess I've come full circle on the class issue.  First I started all against it.  All against it.  As the source of all that is evil and inflexible in RPGs.  Why would anyone want to build a game around the concept of a player taking a sacred oath so their character may forever be what is chosen during character creation?  Why after two decades of beating the dead horse of multiclassing does D&D still miss the point?  Do away with classes, begone evil things from Hades himself.  Or so I though.

I started on a point buy system that could make your character multiclass easily.  A nice set of rules to self balance and off you go.  Want to be a fighter magic user?  No problem.  Thief magic user?  No problem either.  Just plain bad ass figher?  No problem there!

The system works pretty well.  You can be all sorts of magic users.  The nerdy all power spell caster.  A threatening warlock.  A paladin styled heavy armored and magic backed character or just some cleric or monk type wandering the fields.  All was well.

Until I started playtesting it.  Problem was there were so many options it was hard for the unexperienced player to make up his or her mind as to what to include.  If only I had.... mhhhh noooo!!  If there were.... nooooo!! I resisted, and resisted, and resisted to say the dammed word.  The it finally came out as "character templates".  I would not, for the life of me, call it class.  But it is a class.  In a way at least.

So what took me so long to come around to the same point I started from?  Mhhh I felt damned.  All that work for nothing.  I had spent countless hours working up a system that brought me to using the one thing I vowed not to use: the class.  But then it hit me.  The problem with D&D is that its building blocks are classes.  There is no smaller element than class.  Yes there are skills and feats, but that's like left over pieces.  Image a Lego you buy not only prebuilt, but glued together too (a D&D class).  Then Lego out of their good will adds a couple of scattered pieces in the box so you can add to your prebuilt Lego (skills and feats).

Real Lego comes disassembled and in small bags.  It includes a booklet with instructions to build a few models.  You quickly build them and get to play with your Lego.  You build block A with a few pieces.  Then block B and then C.  Put B and C together with some other pieces and get D which you add to A to complete the model.

So in the end I realize that the concept of a class is necessary, but only as the top level item.  It's building blocks are roles which are in turn built up by skills.  Roles are like fields of training and experience.  They group together a set of skills which are know to well define and balance the role.  Characters then multi-role rather than multi-class.

D&D has the pyramid upside down it builds on top of classes and decorates these with skills and feats.  It should take skills and feats, and build roles with that then define classes as a set of roles.  For example a rogue would have a basic role of rogue.  An assassin would have rogue plus a specialization role of assassin.  Game masters can then build roles as they see fit for their campaign setting and customize and intermix them into classes rather then modify the rather inflexible concept of class we have always lived with.

Tuesday, May 08, 2012

Why 2d10 makes sense for skill checks

In my local D&D group I've been discussing the skill check mechanism for 3.5.  In my opinion it makes no sense or at best little sense to have a d20 as a die roll.  First of all its a flat distribution.  Secondly ability bonuses add between 1 and 4.  Yet to get a +4 you need an 18.  That's quite an uncommon value and you only get +4?    So randomness is more significant that character abilities!  More so, training is way more valuable than abilities.  What ever happened to the saying "Quos naturat non dat Salamanca non praestat".  As if any fool could become a master craftsman if he works at it long enough.

As an alternative I've seen 2d10 as die roll suggested and here's some math I see that backs it up.  Let us take a look at the following graph (rendered with http://anydice.com/):


This shows the percentage chance of rolling at least the value on the x axis.  The black line is our well known 1d20 (with its classic 5% steps).  The orange line is the curve for 2d10 (notice it starts at 2).  The blue line is the normal 3d6 ability roll and the green is the more commonly used 4d6 drop the lowest ability roll.

Lets set up a simple rule that says a skill check is done against the skill's ability and the player needs to roll lower than the associated ability to succeed.  Clearly the 2d10 is a tougher roll for characters with a low value.  Rolling a 6 or higher happens 75% of the time with a d20 and nearly 90% of the time with 2d10.  But that's all right if you're dumb your dumb.  Now as you reach 11 and 12 the orange line goes below the black line and it is harder to roll 15 or higher (mess it up) with the 2d10 than with the d20.  Which is also reasonable.  If you're smart you're smart and things begin to get easier.

Now for DCs and training.  Instead of having absurdly high values like DC 20 or what not just have 0 for trivial up to 5 for very hard.  If you add 5 to the 2d10 die roll (equivalent to moving the green line 5 to the left) you see that a character with a 15 ability has a 65% chance of blowing it.   Which is pretty high for an gifted character.  One with 18 would have a 35% chance of blowing.  Your average human with an 11 would blow it 85% of the time.

Training could then go from 0 for basic training to 5 for grand master or some other title you come up with.  A grand master with an ability score of 11 would still succeed 85% of the time.  Showing that mastery in the field counts.  On the other hand an expert with a simple +2, but a 15 ability, would succeed 90% of the time.  A worth while benefit for being gifted by the gods.


Wednesday, May 02, 2012

Graveyard Dungeon

Welcome to the content page of the Graveyard one page dungeon.



You can download the PDF to the dungeon here.

Friday, March 23, 2012

The dugout

How in hell did I get here thought Thorth as he stood in the dark damp room.  His clothes soaked from running in the pouring rain and still no warmth in sight as the woman began lighting a fire.  The cold made him feel miserable.  His beard dripping.  His boots soaked.  He couldn't guess what made him protect this woman in such a way.  He couldn't leave her to those thugs, but on the other hand she had magic and did quite well.  Maybe he shouldn't have gotten involved in the bar fight. She might have gotten away safely and he wouldn't be involved in all this.  He wouldn't be wet either.

"So don't you have a spell to start that fire faster?", asked Thorth with a bit of a grumbling tone.

"Mhhhmphh", replied Mashnauh, "I'm freezing just as much as you are.".  What a grumpy old fart this is, she thought wondering at how she'd gotten involved with him.  Why did she have to get so trigger happy with her spells back at the bar.  If only she'd kept her cool.

"So this is your home?  How long have you been living here?", asked Thorth while eyeing the place.  Clearly some type of catacomb or storage far below the city streets.  They'd arrived there through the sewers and underground river.  Made him wonder what this woman was doing and how she knew this city's underground so well.

"A few months.", replied Mashnauh.

"A few months, hmmm", he said looking around.  Sure didn't look like she's been here just a few months.   Way to much stuff and well settled for just a few months.  "So I take it you're not from here, are you?"

"No, I'm from the steppes to the south.  That's were I was born and grew there with my family."

"What brings you to the city?"

"I'm looking for something that was taken from me."

"Must be a very valuable something to be this far north.", said Thorth as he approached the fire which was picking up now.

"Yes, I'm looking for my sister. She was taken by a slaver an evil mage actually.  A tattoo mage who's used his magic on her to take  her from us."

"A tattoo mage?", asked Thorth.

"Yes.  A very powerful type of talismanic magic.  Tattoo mages turn their bodies into walking scrolls and magic items.  Each tattoo has a spell power.  This mage has used some of the most powerful type of tattoo to entrap my sisters soul in his skin and make her his slave.  To the point she'd kill me if I tried to save her.", said Mashnuah breaking into tears.  "I need to find the magic to stop the spell before I can recover her.  She she", said Mashnuah between sobs, "she won't come with me willingly."

"Now now there I'm sure things will turn out right and good fortune will shine on your path.", replied Thorth stretching his hands uncertain how to comfort her.  Grumbling softly he brought his hands back to his sides.

"Oh no I know I won't.  I blew it tonight I should have kept my cool, but those guys grrrrrrr.  Oh I should have waited.  Now I don't know if he'll want to meet with me again.", she said breaking into tears.

"A contact I had. A smuggler actually.  He was going to help me infiltrate the city and contact me there with someone to help me find my sister.  But now he's gone and I have no way to get there."

Thorth began to feel it again.  That sense that he was about to help her in something he was going to regret later.  Why did a grumpy old fart like him have a soft spot for this woman he'd just met.





Sunday, March 18, 2012

A glimpse of history


I've stumbled upon a great treasure chest.  It's wealth unimaginable.  Within it I've found magical scrolls like this one.  Dating back to 1992, I can't believe it'll be 20 years this December.  Engraved on the scroll are simple rules that back then represented certain aspects of combat that were not in the base rules and which we developed to add flavour to our adventures.  These rules are the last I DMed as a few months later I would leave home for college and never look back.  Until now.

Twenty years later a force I thought dead in me is surging to life with a power never before thought possible.  As if these homerules had been brewing in my subconscious for decades.  Coming back with the full force of fantasy role play.  Pushing me to write down idea after idea and bringing me back to the same group of people who wrote these homerules.  With them I am writing a whole new game to play the same old game.

These scrolls are a reminder of what this game is about.  Adventure.  Back then there was no internet.  Way down south, closer to Antarctica tan the Equator each rule book was a treasure in itself.  There were no PDFs, no extra modules nor hundreds of products we now take for granted.  It was three or four books and your imagination and we did wonderful things with just that.

As I sit back now writing new rules for Era I'm greatly inspired by these memories.  They remind me what the game is all about.  This couldn't come at a better moment.  With my old gaming group scattered over three continents, brought together by today's technology, I'm reminded that there is a world where time doesn't pass, were good friends are friends forever and adventure always awaits the brave and courageous.  That world is D&D and it lives strong in all our hearts.

Gerardo

Thursday, March 15, 2012

A quick drink and we're out

Thorth feels a soft draft build as the door is opened letting the chilly wind of a rainy day break in.  He knows a woman just walked in.  This place doesn't get this quiet without a cause and women usually don't come here unless they have a reason.  He brushes his eyebrow and plays with his beard without turning around to see her as she approaches the bar.  He just keeps an eye on the reflexion on the wall mirror.  A medium height slender woman dressed in a heavy rain coat.  She walks quietly and cautiously to the bar.

"Something strong to ward of the cold", she says dropping a coin to the bartender for pay.

"I can help you with that cold of yours sweetie", says a voice a few meters behind.

Oh oh, here comes trouble says Thorth to himself as a man steps up from the nearest table and approaches the bar.

"Maybe I can get you something warmer than that there whiskey, honey"

"No thank you, I'm fine.", replies the woman.

"I insist honey."

"Don't insist too much or you might regret it."

"What could I regret darling?  It's cold and rainy outside and we are in here warm and enjoying a drink together.  You and I."

"I'm enjoying a drink and you're beginning to annoy me."

"I'm not that annoying once you get to know me better.", replies the man as the woman turns up to him and says in a low whisper, "Schnak shni mush na".

The man makes a motion as if to speak, but can't seem to open his mouth and utter a single word.  His hands reach up to his mouth to try and understand what is going on.

"I told you so, boy.", says the woman.

The man stumbles back to his table unable to speak.  His gestures calling the attention of his friends.

"Witch!! She's a witch!!", screams one of them.  The two men on the table stand up and rush the woman.  She, still holding a hand towards the muted man utters the words "Span uk nak" and one of them flies backwards as if pushed by a gigantic force. She turns to the second man, "Span uk nak" and he too goes flying backwards and lands on his back.

"Oh no you don't", says Thorth as he sees a fourth man rush the woman from the side with a short dagger.  He stands in front and parries the blow with his sword.  The man  turns to him and attacks.

Rolling a 20 he hits Thorth dead on.  Rolls 2d4 for his dagger and Thorth 2d6.  Dagger's 3 and 2 are no match for the armors 5 and 2.

"Wrong move.", replies Thorth and he swings a 12 hitting the man.  He rolls a 6 for his swords damage and the man's leather only  manages a 3 and a 3.  The 6 points go straight through and cause 2 points to the leather armor and 4 to the man who is injured.  The man steps back as Thorth swings again and misses.

"Span uk nak", and the injured man is also projected backwards.

"Come", says the woman behind Thorth and she points to the door.  He turns and charges as a man stands to block it with another sword.  Thorth wins the initiative, swings a 14 hitting the man.  He tries to parry with his weapon but has no luck with a 2.  Thorth swings 4 points of damage and the man's leather holds with a roll of 4 and 3.  The man swings with a 14 hitting Thorth who can't parry with his roll of a 5.  The sword delivers 2 points of damage which are easily stopped by the Thorth's armor roll of 3 and 1.

The woman runs behind Thorth and yells at him to go out the door, "This way now".  Thorth glimpses backwards and begins a fighting retreat.  He swings a 9 and misses.  The man swings an 11 and it is parried by Thorth's 11.  Thorth swings an 18 which is not parried (7 rolled) and the man takes 5 points of damage as his armor can't protect him that much (roll 2 & 1).  The armor takes 2 and the man 3.  Irritated he tries to swing at Thorth as they reach the bar's entrance.  The now familiar chant of "Span uk nak" pushes the wounded man inside and the woman closes the door.

"An Auh Mi Na Sa", chants the woman at the door as she points down the street.

Thorth starts moving in the indicated direction followed by the woman who keeps pointing her hand at the door while she chants, "Mi Na Sa", "Mi Na Sa".  Loud banging is going on inside the bar and it is clear she is holding the door in some magical way.

They turn into a dark alley and the woman stops chanting.  Looking up at him their eyes finally meet, "Runnn!!!!" she yells.


Game Masters Notes

Mashnauh, the woman in our story, has helped our hero and herself escape the brawl in the bar.  By casting a few spells she cleared the way for her escape.  But she is now about half way down her mana points, having casted: Silence (7, 5 mana + 1/round), two Push (6, 3 mana each), another Push (3) and yet another Push (3) on the way out, plus a Hold Object to keep the door shut (7, 3 + 1 / round).  That's 26 points and leaves her with only 34 for whatever comes next.  At least 5 hours will need to go by for her to regain that so escape was the best alternative for now.  She didn't find who she was looking for, but this new found acquaintance might just fit in.

Thorth Drk

Thorth Drk is my new dwarven character created with the Era Rulebook.  I'll be posting his stats and progression on this blog as he adventures through the wilderness of his homeland.  First off lets get him rolled up.  Base attributes are STR, INT, WILL, DEX, CON and CHI.

STR 14
INT 11
WILL 14
DEX 12
CON 10
CHI 14

Some attributes have bonuses, but none add any role points which are used to purchase initial abilities and skills.  Thus Thorth starts with 10 role points.  He decides to spend two on raising his Stamina Point roll from 1d4 to 1d8, a hardened dwarf as he is.  He purchases a mana role to have some magic spirit in him and gets 3d4x10 initial mana plus 2d4x10 per upgrade.  And finally gets some will points just in case I ever finish implementing psionics giving him 2d4x10 initial will points (WP) and 1d4x10 per upgrade.  These purchases add some tax on his XP: 1.0% for SP, 1.0% for mana and 0.5% for will power.

He then rolls hit points, stamina points, mana and will power.

HP : CON + 1d10 = 10 + 9 = 19
SP : CON + 1d8 + CON bonus = 10 +3 + 0 = 13
Pain Threshold PT : ceiling (13 * .2) = ceiling (2.6) = 3
Mana : 2d4 x 10 = 70
Will Points : 2d4 x 10 = 50

For skills and collegia he purchases Parabellum to be a good fighter and gets a swords and bow proficiency which allows him to use swords and bows.  This costs him 5 role points in total plus the 5 he spent on stamina and such leaving him dry.  He'll need to adventure to get more role points to purchase more skills.  Adding the xp Tax for these skills (5% Parabellum, 1% sword, 1% bow) to the base XP tax we get 8.5% tax.  That means that each role point that costs 2000 XP will cost him 2186 XP.

With his combat collegia trained he has two attacks per round and suffers no penalties in combat.  He also has a +1 damage bonus from strength with hand held weapons.

He gears up with a sword that does 1d8, a bow and some arrows that deliver 1d8 and chainmail that has 120 damage capacity points (DC) a 3 armor rating (AR) and protects with a 2d6 die roll.

All settled and ready to go he waits at the inn's bar waiting for adventure to walk in while he sips his ale.

Monday, March 12, 2012

Hit Roll Aliasing, D&D's biggest issue

I never though I'd use digital signal processing terms in D&D, but here I am.  There are various issues with the D&D gaming system.  The one I believe stands out is combat.  Clearly it has the most convoluted set of auxiliary rules, addendums and tables.  Over the years I've though about what the issue was.  What was the core problem.  Now if I have to put a word to it it is aliasing.  Aliasing is, as wikipedia puts it, " an effect that causes different signals to become indistinguishable [from one another]" . In D&D the d20 system makes it difficult to tell events from one another.  Just like a low sampling rate makes it impossible to digitalize a high frequency signal, so does the d20 system fall short in representing all the events involved in a sword swing.

D&D tries to cram all the events, effects and outcomes in a single number called "to hit roll".  Which is more like the "to damage roll" since once you succeed in it damage is rolled.  If it were really a hit roll it would not include attack bonuses, defense bonuses, parry and dodge bonuses, etc etc etc.  You add all the good things and the bad things and then some, put a d20 roll into the mix and come up with a value that somehow represents your success at making someone very miserable.

We are basically adding a bunch of signals into one value:

Attach Bonus = Base attack bonus + Strength modifier + size modifier

Armor Class = 10 + armor bonus + shield bonus + Dexterity modifier + size modifier + {Enhancement, Deflection, Dodge etc bonuses}

Then "sampling" it with a d20, which has only twenty "5% chance sampling points" and on top of that some may mean something and some not.  For example some character might need only a 3 or more on the d20 while others might need a 19 or 20 to hit their target.  So what does a 12 mean?  Does it mean I moved a ton of air with my sword?  Does it mean I hit the target, but the armor was too strong?  Does it mean I was going to hit the target, but just on the last second he dodged?

My recommendation to D&D, keep those signals separate and sample them independently.  Have a real "to hit" roll.  Give characters the opportunity to parry, dodge or catch the arrows in a separate action.  Then face off the weapon vs the armor "mano a mano" and see what happens.  But if you keep mixing signals you'll end up with rules like these:

Dodge : + 1 dodge bonus against an opponent (no matter how many attacks the opponent has)
Deflect Arrows : Once per round you can try to deflect an arrow.

One adds a value to the die roll and applies to all opponents, the other can only be used once per round.  That type of inconsistencies and add-on rules drive me nuts.  Why not look at other games and see how they have actions and they can be used to attack or defend?  They each have bonuses for that action be it parry or dodge or catch or whatever.  You can dodge as many times as YOU, not your attacker has actions.  Dodge bonuses apply to your dodge roll.  You can deflect arrows as many times as you have actions, not an artificial once per round.

By keeping the actions separate: "to hit", "to evade hit" and then "to damage".  The events are easier to view and the game easier to balance.  More so since you haven't "mixed these signals" you have more detail in the attack, better story telling and less need for tables later on to sort out your "aliased signals".

Friday, March 09, 2012

A case for lower hit points

Last night I was chatting with a friend of mine and good role player.  Like me he hasn't played D&D for quite some time, but has quite a bit of experience and good points as to what makes or does not make a good aventure.  Anyway, getting back on track, he was making the point that characters should not have many hit points.  Which is quite contradictory with common gaming dogma.  After all isn't that the whole point of raising level?

Well yes, but it also tends to do two things: make the character quite hard to kill and "deprecate" local monsters.  This put together with an ever more ambitious search for XP leads us to the "runaway character" or "runaway party".  By runaway I don't mean that literally.  It is more on the lines of a nuclear reaction and the party is quite literally on a runaway chain reaction.  More XP leads to more levels which leads to more hit points which leads to bigger monsters that give even more XP.  This is partially fuelled by the fact that the main source of XP is killing and gold.  So on top of the local Gnoll village becoming irrelevant the whole economy begins to go down the drain due to excess gold.

Now what if characters didn't gain hit points or gained less hit points than usual?  Obviously they would be more vulnerable unless they were harder to hit.  Which leads me to the core of my friends point.  Characters should not gain hit points, they should gain skills that protect them from harm.  And I agree with him.  Without so many hit points the character is almost as vulnerable to a hit as in lesser levels.  The character is simply harder to hit.  So monsters don't need to go into an ascending spiral of toughness.  There would be less difference between a 1st level monster and a 10th level monster.  This leads to more manageable adventures.

Characters can still become super powerful and kill big monsters, but they won't be as invulnerable now.  And that leads to more epic fights.  Face it if you know you can stand and deliver and you're pretty much a hit point wall what worry do you have?  You just keep rolling until the character succumbs.  Now if you're vulnerable you'll pick your fights a lot better and play them out a lot smarter and so will monsters.  So battles will become better, more entertaining and more epic.